Choosing between Deezer and Spotify used to be simple. If you owned a pair of expensive Sennheisers and cared about bitrates, you picked Deezer. If you wanted to share playlists with your friends and have the app work on your toaster, you picked Spotify.
But here we are in late 2025, and the landscape has completely shifted. With Spotify finally rolling out its long-awaited Spotify Lossless audio tier, the single biggest differentiator—sound quality—has largely evaporated. I have spent the last six weeks living with both apps, importing my library back and forth, and letting their algorithms dictate my mood.
The gap has closed, but the differences in "personality" are starker than ever. If you are stuck on the fence in the great Deezer vs Spotify debate, here is the honest truth about which one deserves your monthly subscription.
Round 1: Sound Quality (The Audiophile's Dilemma)
For years, Deezer held the crown here. But as of September 2025, the playing field is technically level.
Both services now offer Lossless Audio (CD-quality FLAC at 16-bit/44.1kHz) for their Premium subscribers. When I tested Daft Punk's Random Access Memories on both platforms using a DAC and wired headphones, the difference was indistinguishable. The crispness of the hi-hats and the depth of the bass were present on both. Spotify has finally caught up.
However, the Free Tier story is different.
If you plan to use the service without paying, Spotify wins by a mile. Deezer's free tier is capped at 128kbps MP3, and frankly, it sounds thin and muddy, like an old radio broadcast. Spotify Free streams at roughly 160kbps (Ogg Vorbis), which, while compressed, retains much more dynamic range and punch.
My Take: If you are paying for Premium, it's a tie. If you are a free user, avoid Deezer unless you enjoy hearing digital artifacts in your cymbals.
Round 2: Music Discovery & Algorithms
This is where the apps show their true colors. It comes down to whether you prefer a "human" touch or a "social" one.
Deezer's "Flow": The Mood Setter
Deezer feels like that friend who quietly observes you and then hands you a mixtape saying, "I think you need this right now". Their signature feature, Flow, is an infinite mix that blends your favorites with new recommendations.
In my experience, Flow is surprisingly good at reading the room. It doesn't just loop the same Top 40 hits; it digs into deep cuts and genres you haven't touched in a while. It feels less algorithmic and more organic.
Spotify's AI DJ & Smart Shuffle
Spotify, on the other hand, wants to be the life of the party. The AI DJ (X) creates a radio-show experience, complete with a synthesized voice introducing tracks. It's impressive tech, but sometimes I just want music, not a robot telling me it's "a Tuesday vibe".
Where Spotify truly dominates is Social Discovery. If you want to see what your friends are listening to, share a "Blend" playlist that automatically mixes your tastes with a partner's, or participate in the cultural phenomenon of Spotify Wrapped, there is no competition. Spotify is a social network; Deezer is a music player.
Round 3: Pricing and Value (The Hidden Deezer Win)
Most people assume the pricing is identical, but if you look closely at the Deezer vs Spotify price structure, there is a hidden gem for budget-conscious listeners.
| Plan Type | Spotify (Monthly) | Deezer (Monthly) | The "Hidden" Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Individual | $11.99 | $11.99 | Tie (Monthly) |
| Annual Plan | Not Available | $107.99 / year | Deezer (Saves ~$36/year) |
| Duo (2 people) | $16.99 | $15.99 | Deezer ($1 cheaper/mo) |
| Family (6 people) | $19.99 | $19.99 | Tie (Monthly) |
| Student | $5.99 | $5.99 | Spotify (Includes Hulu w/ Ads) |
| Free Trial | 3-4 Months (Promo*) | 1 Month | Spotify (Better on-boarding) |
On a monthly basis, both Individual Premium plans hover around the standard $11.99/month mark. However, Deezer offers an Annual Plan. By paying for a year upfront, you get a discount of roughly 25%.
If you are committed to a service, Deezer saves you over $30 a year. Spotify rarely offers direct discounts on Individual plans, relying instead on Duo or Family bundles to provide value.
The "Ownership" Problem: Why You Are Still Renting Your Music
Despite the features, both platforms share a frustrating flaw common to all streaming services: Digital Rights Management (DRM).
Even with Spotify's new Lossless tier, you don't actually own the music. You are renting access to it. This creates real limitations that I ran into constantly during my testing:
- 1 The 30-Day Leash: You must go online with your device at least once every 30 days. If you don't—say, you leave an old phone in your car or go on a long camping trip—Spotify deletes your offline downloads.
- 2 Device Limits: You are capped at 10,000 downloads per device on a maximum of 5 devices.
- 3 App Lock-in: You cannot take those "downloaded" files and play them on an MP3 player, burn them to a CD, or use them in DJ software. They are encrypted cache files that only Spotify can read.
This is where I stopped relying solely on the apps and started using a workaround to actually secure my library.
The Solution: DRmare Spotify Music Converter
I use DRmare Spotify Music Converter as an "insurance policy" for my playlists. It bridges the gap between the convenience of streaming and the ownership of buying files.
DRmare is a specialized tool that downloads Spotify songs, playlists, and albums as genuine local files (MP3, FLAC, WAV, etc.). It removes the DRM protection, meaning you can listen to your music offline forever, without the 30-day login requirement or device limits.
What makes it particularly useful for the "Deezer vs Spotify" debate is the quality retention. Since Spotify now streams Lossless, DRmare can capture that high-fidelity audio and save it as FLAC on your hard drive.
Final Verdict: Which One Fits You?
The battle is closer than ever, but the choice comes down to your lifestyle.
You should choose Spotify if:
- You care about social features and want to share music easily.
- You listen to Podcasts heavily (Spotify is the superior all-in-one app).
- You are a Free user and want the best non-paid experience.
- You want the "Standard" experience that works on every device imaginable.
You should choose Deezer if:
- Budget is a priority: The Annual Plan offers significant savings.
- You hate clutter: You want a music-focused interface without podcasts and audiobooks pushing into your feed.
- You prefer "Flow": You want a set-it-and-forget-it radio that feels more human than algorithmic.
For me, the social pull of Spotify keeps me subscribed. However, I refuse to let a monthly payment dictate my access to my favorite songs. That is why I pair it with DRmare—it gives me the best discovery features of Spotify with the permanent ownership of a personal music collection.
Home
User Comments
Leave a Comment